I made you a sandwich.
That made me laugh. This was an original and interesting game for me, I quickly found out how it all worked and ended up being a 600 HP behemoth just before the prom. There's a bit of humour, and although I had to play as a GIRL I didn't actually mind too much, since most of the guys looked like girls and I could just pretend to be a guy. Quite a sweet game, and it's one that I'll remember for far longer than most others on this site.
If you added sound effects and slightly more variation between the places it could have been better, but this is a great start. Having to choose what to say, then move my cursor up to the top of the screen to talk again got annoying. Perhaps you could use keyboard buttons to navigate these chat menus as well as the mouse.